Friday, February 8, 2008

Pondering Benson & 5th Starter Candidates

The Phillies seem to be a lot more interested in free agent RHP Kris Benson than they've let on. After a ho-hum throwing session in December, Benson has quietly thrown for Phillies scouts twice in the past week or so and has shown enough to start somewhat of a buzz.

Go ahead and sign him. Benson is willing to take a one-year, incentive-laden contract. It gives you another arm at the back of the rotation. Best case scenario: He performs as well as a number three starter. Worst case: He gets hurt, doesn't contribute and you plug in one of the guys who you were prepared to stick at the back of the rotation in the first place.

What are the other options? Chad Durbin has experience as both a starter and reliever, making him ideal for long relief and spot starts. Adam Eaton is better suited for bagging groceries than throwing a baseball. Farmhands like Carlos Carrasco and Joshua Outman are at least a year away from the big leagues.

The darkhorse who nobody seems to be mentioning is J.D. Durbin. He's a cocky former top prospect who had control problems until he stopped trying to throw every pitch through a brick wall. He threw a couple gems last season and has the potential to be solid if he can put it all together. Don't be surprised if J.D. Durbin grabs the last spot in the rotation with a strong Spring Training.

As for Kris Benson, why not? It's a no-lose situation for both sides. After all, your top division rival did just sign a guy named Johan.

Memo to Anna Benson... if you think you were heckled in New York and Baltimore, do not tempt the Phillies Phaithful.

No comments: